Japanese noodle showdown: soba vs udon. There’s lots to like relating to noodles in Japan. At first look, it could seem to be soba and udon are interchangeable. Whereas each are scrumptious, there are just a few key variations. Let’s break down elements, textures and the perfect recipes for every.
What’s Soba
Soba noodles are lengthy, skinny Japanese noodles fabricated from buckwheat flour and water – and typically a portion of wheat flour (extra on this in a sec). They’ve a refined nutty style and and might differ in texture from chewy and springy – to dense and mildly grainy. This variation in texture from model to model is determined by the quantity of buckwheat utilized in manufacturing. Common rule: extra wheat flour, the smoother and springy the feel – extra buckwheat, extra dense.
Japanese buckwheat noodles are steadily served in soups (each cold and hot) and in salads. Soba also can differ in colour from gentle gray to brown.
What are Soba Noodles Made From
Soba is usually comprised of buckwheat flour and water. Nevertheless, there are a number of variations in soba manufacturing that decide what share of buckwheat is used – and if wheat flour is used as a binding agent. Salt is usually added as nicely.
- Juwari Soba: 100% buckwheat flour and water.
- Hachiwari Soba: 20% wheat and 80% buckwheat. The wheat flour is used as a binding agent. That is nonetheless thought of genuine Japanese soba.
- There are additionally variations of soba which have a a lot increased ratio of wheat flour to buckwheat flour. They typically seem lighter in colour.
Typically further flavoring brokers are utilized in soba. For instance, cha soba is flavored with inexperienced tea powder – and jinenjo soba makes use of nagaimo (mountain yam).
What’s Buckwheat Flour
Buckwheat flour is constituted of floor buckwheat seeds. However buckwheat just isn’t truly from the wheat household in any respect. As a substitute it comes from the identical household of crops as rhubarb. It’s a pseudo-grain. Different pseudo-grains embody quinoa and amaranth.
Buckwheat flour is gluten free and has a light nutty taste with grassy notes. The flour is combined with water (and typically a portion of wheat flour) to kind a dough which is rolled and sliced to make soba noodles.
Shopping for Soba Noodles
In the case of shopping for soba on the grocery retailer, there are sometimes two choices: fresh-frozen and dry.
- Dry soba is helpful to maintain within the pantry since it’s shelf-stable and cooks pretty rapidly. Nevertheless there will be some variation within the elements utilized in manufacturing from model to model (i.e. excessive salt content material or excessive wheat flour content material). I are inclined to favor dry soba with a really brief elements checklist and a excessive ratio of buckwheat flour.
- The fresh-frozen choices at Japanese grocery shops (in LA at the least) are usually premium soba noodles. Normally the juwari or hachiwari (nihachi) soba – and are completely scrumptious.
Notice: Be typically cautious of shelf secure, precooked soba that doesn’t require refrigeration. Other than sub-par taste and texture, these noodles additionally are inclined to include a ton of preservatives.
Cooking Soba Noodles
A easy rule of thumb is to comply with the cooking directions on the bundle, since there will probably be variation in boiling occasions from model to model. Dry noodles are often accomplished in round 3-5 minutes.
Drain and rinse soba below chilly water if it’s being utilized in a chilly recipe like zaru soba.
Noodles going into scorching soup will proceed cooking within the broth, so drain them when al dente and use instantly.
Soba Recipes
Soba noodles are steadily served both inside a scorching soup – or on their very own in chilly preparations, with a extremely concentrated broth on the facet. Listed here are some in style soba dishes.
- Zaru Soba: Chilly soba noodles dipped right into a savory mentsuyu dipping sauce fabricated from dashi, soy sauce and mirin. Wasabi is non-obligatory. This is likely one of the most iconic summertime soba preparations in Japan.
- Toshikoshi Soba: Soba served in a heat tsuyu broth – historically served on New 12 months’s Eve (I’ve added boiled eggs to this explicit recipe, however it’s sometimes served with out).
- Tempura Soba: Tensoba options veggies and shrimp which have been fried in a light-weight batter till crispy. Widespread greens embody kabocha squash, lotus root, shiso leaves, and many others. Shrimp tempura is essentially the most iconic addition. Tempura soba will be served scorching or chilly.
- Naengmyeon: This can be a chilly Korean soba noodle recipe that includes a savory and briny broth made with dongchimi (Korean radish water / pickle brine).
Is Soba Wholesome?
Soba noodles are pretty excessive in protein and heart-healthy fiber – and low in easy carbohydrates and energy. This is because of the usage of buckwheat flour which is thought of a superfood.
Since buckwheat flour is a fancy carbohydrate, soba can maintain you feeling full for longer because the physique processes all these carbs slowly.
Soba is usually thought of extra wholesome than udon. Nevertheless you will need to observe two issues:
- Solely soba made with 100% buckwheat flour is gluten free.
- Advanced carbohydrates can typically be taxing on a delicate digestive system. Udon may be a more sensible choice when you’re feeling below the climate with a tummy bug or want a softer food regimen usually.
What’s Udon
Udon noodles are thick, springy Japanese noodles fabricated from wheat flour, water and salt. Recognized primarily for his or her bounce and chewiness, these noodles are generally utilized in Japanese soups and stir fries. Whereas such a noodle has a light taste of its personal, udon absorbs extra liquid than soba – which means that udon noodles soak within the flavors of your broth or stir fry very nicely.
Udon noodles are white in colour and will be flat or spherical.
Udon Noodle Substances
The elements checklist for udon is pretty easy: all-purpose wheat flour, water and salt. It’s kneaded right into a dough, and reduce into strips. Residence cooks making udon from scratch will use cornstarch or potato starch to maintain the noodles from sticking collectively after they’ve been reduce.
Udon Variations
When shopping for udon noodles on the grocery retailer you’ll discover dry, frozen and contemporary refrigerated variations.
- Frozen udon noodles are sometimes pre-cooked after which flash frozen. So that they prepare dinner reasonably rapidly in a pot of boiling water – often 2-3 minutes.
- Dry udon tends to take longer – round 7-10 minutes.
As at all times, comply with the cooking directions on the bundle for greatest outcomes.
Udon Recipes
Udon noodles are sometimes served in soup, however are generally stir-fried as nicely. Listed here are some in style udon dishes.
- Fundamental Udon Soup: The nice and cozy dashi inventory based mostly broth is complimented by soy sauce, mirin and kombu – and the noodle soup is topped with nori and shiitake mushrooms. A stripped down model of this dish (sometimes with simply the new broth and shaved inexperienced onions) is named kake udon in Japanese.
- Kitsune Udon: The direct translation of kitsune udon is ‘fox udon.’ And that’s probably a nod to the colour of the deep fried tofu pouches (referred to as aburaage / or inari age) served within the soup. Widespread toppings embody fish truffles and chopped scallions. By the way, kitsune udon is my favourite!
- Curry Udon: The dashi based mostly broth is fortified with savory Japanese curry. It’s hearty consolation meals that originated in the course of the Meiji interval in Tokyo.
- Yaki Udon: These chewy udon noodles are stir fried in a easy umami combination of butter, dashi and soy sauce – then topped with nori and bonito flakes (katsuobushi). Try this video to see how easy it’s to make yaki udon at residence (5 minutes or much less!) together with 4 different straightforward important Japanese recipes.
- Kimchi Udon Stir Fry: This is likely one of the noodle dishes that basically reveals off udon’s versatility. As a result of udon’s secret weapon is that it absorbs no matter taste you throw at it (bacon and kimchi on this case). High with a fried egg for the complete expertise.
Is Udon Wholesome?
Whereas udon noodles are low in fats, they’re additionally pretty low in important vitamins on their very own. Many of the well being advantages you’ll get from consuming udon will come from the soup broth and / or further elements you select so as to add to any given recipe. That mentioned, udon is sort of at all times a more healthy noodle alternative than one thing like on the spot ramen.
Since udon noodles are made with wheat flour, they aren’t gluten-free.
In the case of soba vs udon – the more healthy alternative is usually soba because of the buckwheat.
Soba vs Udon: The Essential Takeaways
Listed here are the important thing variations between udon and soba:
- Substances: Soba is made both solely from buckwheat flour – or a mix of buckwheat flour and wheat flour. Udon is constituted of 100% wheat flour.
- Look and Texture: Udon are thick, white noodles with a slippery, bouncy chewiness and impartial taste profile – however they take in extra cooking flavors than soba. Soba noodles are thinner with a dense texture and a naturally nutty taste.
- Diet: Soba is excessive in fiber because of the buckwheat flour, but has a barely increased calorie rely than udon. Udon is increased in easy carbohydrates, however could also be extra mild to digest.
Subscribe to my publication and obtain the newest recipes and weekly favorites straight to your inbox. Be a part of me on Pinterest, Fb, and Instagram for extra cooking suggestions and adventures!
So the place do you fall on the soba vs udon spectrum? Do you will have a favourite? Inform me about your favourite soba and udon recipes within the feedback part!
Want Extra Noodles? Test Out These Simple Ramen Recipes
